header parallax image
Mairead McGuinness MEP
  • HOME
  • About Mairead
    • About Mairead
    • PICTURES
    • TRANSPARENCY
  • NEWS
    • AGRICULTURE
    • BREXIT
    • CHILDREN & YOUNG PEOPLE
    • ENVIRONMENT
    • EVENTS
    • FOOD SAFETY
    • FUTURE OF EUROPE
    • HEALTH
    • INTERRELIGIOUS DIALOGUE
    • LATEST NEWS
    • TRADE
  • GALLERY
    • GALLERY
    • VIDEOS
  • CONTACT
  • HOME
  • About Mairead
    • About Mairead
    • PICTURES
    • TRANSPARENCY
  • NEWS
    • AGRICULTURE
    • BREXIT
    • CHILDREN & YOUNG PEOPLE
    • ENVIRONMENT
    • EVENTS
    • FOOD SAFETY
    • FUTURE OF EUROPE
    • HEALTH
    • INTERRELIGIOUS DIALOGUE
    • LATEST NEWS
    • TRADE
  • GALLERY
    • GALLERY
    • VIDEOS
  • CONTACT
AGRICULTUREENVIRONMENT

Glyphosate Debate – If Politicians Can’t Trust Science On What Do We Base Policy?

October 12, 2017 November 16, 2017 Mairead McGuinness1360 views

The debate about glyphosate raises the serious question that if policymakers cannot trust scientific data then on what can they base their policies, Mairead McGuinness, first Vice-President of the European Parliament, has said.

Speaking in the European Parliament following a public hearing on ‘The Monsanto Papers and Glyphosate’ she said: “In this hearing we heard nothing new, just a repeat of the scientific evidence and advice from our EU agencies, EFSA and ECHA that Glyphosate is not a carcinogen. This is advice and guidance that I accept.”

She said against that there are others saying that it is a carcinogen and must be banned and accusing Monsanto of “ghost writing” scientific studies.

“The most telling and disturbing comment in this hearing came from European Corporate Observatory, which opposes the re-licensing of glyphosate and asked the question, ‘What do we do about farmers who face the choice of cancer or losses’.

“We should not underestimate the lobby to ban glyphosate. But we also need to understand that for many decades glyphosate has proven itself to be an effective tool for farmers, and there is no safe substitute product that we know of.”

Ms McGuinness said even those who want it banned admit that there will be huge consequences for European agriculture.

“There is also the reality that none of our trading partners today or potential partners in the future are likely to ban this product. So if member states refuse to give their approval for it to be licensed beyond the end of this year, it will no longer be available to farmers, yet we will import animal feed and raw materials produced using glyphosate products.”

She added that there is one area of concern that regulators do need to address and that is the issue of co-formulants used with glyphosate.

“The European Parliament’s glyphosate resolution supported the withdrawing of products containing a formulation of POE – tallowamine and glyphosate because of real concerns about its safety.

“If EFSA, ECHA, and the environment protection agencies of Japan, Canada and Australia have all concluded that glyphosate is not a carcinogen, yet there are claims to the contrary, then policy makers (who are not toxicologists) are left with a stark choice to rely on the scientific expertise of the agencies we know and fund or ignore them.”

“We risk downgrading our regulatory system, denying farmers an important production tool and unnecessarily causing fears among citizens about products which have helped to produce food in abundance in the EU,” she concluded.

On October 25th the future of glyphosate in the EU is expected to be voted on when member states will be required to show their support for its approval or vote to ban the product.

This vote will have a major impact on EU farmers and our food production system, McGuinness warned.

Mairead McGuinnessOctober 12, 2017

Categories

  • AGRICULTURE
  • BREXIT
  • CHILDREN & YOUNG PEOPLE
  • ENVIRONMENT
  • EVENTS
  • FOOD SAFETY
  • FUTURE OF EUROPE
  • HEALTH
  • INTERRELIGIOUS DIALOGUE
  • LATEST NEWS
  • MAIREAD
  • TIMELINE
  • TRADE
  • TRANSPARENCY
  • VIDEOS

Twitter

Tweets by MaireadMcGMEP

Facebook

Mairead McGuinness MEP

INSTAGRAM

mcguinnesseu

Vice-President of the European Parliament and MEP for the Midlands-North-West region of Ireland. Member of the EPP Group.

Press conference on the Commission's vision for fo Press conference on the Commission's vision for fostering openness, strength & resilience in Europe’s economic and financial system 🇪🇺

To strengthen Europe’s economic and financial system in a changing global context, we want:
🔵 a stronger international role of the euro
🔵 more resilient financial market infrastructures
🔵 effective implementation of EU sanctions.
College of Commissioners on Christmas Eve debriefi College of Commissioners on Christmas Eve debriefing about 🇪🇺🇬🇧 deal. 

Congratulations and thank you to @ursulavonderleyen, Michel Barnier and team.
First press conference as Commissioner this week t First press conference as Commissioner this week to launch @europeancommission strategy on non-performing loans
Many people have asked me about the impact of COVI Many people have asked me about the impact of COVID on my new role.
Congratulations President-elect @JoeBiden it was a Congratulations President-elect @JoeBiden it was a pleasure to welcome you to Co Louth 🇮🇪 in 2016, along with members of your family. I look forward to a strong EU 🇪🇺 🇺🇸 US relationship under your presidency. Congratulations @KamalaHarris 👏
.... a perch for the birds in the garden.... .... a perch for the birds in the garden....
Load More... Follow on Instagram
Copyright © 2016 Mairead McGuinness - Designed and Managed by exSite